Genealogy Chat

Top tip - using the Genes Reunited community

Welcome to the Genes Reunited community boards!

  • The Genes Reunited community is made up of millions of people with similar interests. Discover your family history and make life long friends along the way.
  • You will find a close knit but welcoming group of keen genealogists all prepared to offer advice and help to new members.
  • And it's not all serious business. The boards are often a place to relax and be entertained by all kinds of subjects.
  • The Genes community will go out of their way to help you, so don’t be shy about asking for help.

Quick Search

Single word search

Icons

  • New posts
  • No new posts
  • Thread closed
  • Stickied, new posts
  • Stickied, no new posts

Seaman's Discharge Book - Incorrect info

Page 0 + 1 of 2

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. »
ProfilePosted byOptionsPost Date

Kala

Kala Report 8 Feb 2017 15:27

Thank you all for your help. She recalls Olive as looking like an old woman but she admits that she was in reality probably only about 60(ish) so that could be her born in 1927. We do have a few couple of coloured photos of Thomas and this backs up my mothers description of him, very dark skinned and dark features. I also called my uncle, who is older than my mother and would have been around 26 when Thomas died for his description of him and he gave the same description: dark dark skin and almost black eyes - he described them as 'crow like'. He also said he had often wondered growing up if Thomas had been illegitimately conceived with one of the Arab's that populated the area at the time and George and infact not actually been his father.

I do agree that a life at sea can definitely weather a man but in Thomas' case he was chef in the kitchen and only went up and down the coast of England, his career at sea also only last 8 years.

My grandfather, uncle and mother (Thomas' son and grandchildren) are all very dark skinned, all have lovely brown eyes - big, dark and round like malteasers! - and brown hair so dark it could pass for black in some lights. My grandfather was Thomas' absoloute double.

AustinQ

AustinQ Report 7 Feb 2017 15:23

Just looking at Thomas CR1 card- his description matches his fathers almost exactly:

5ft 4inches
Blue eyes
Brown hair
Complexion fair

At the time he was a fresh faced young lad of 18 or 19. I should image a life on the seas would weather any man!
--------------------------------------------

I note Thomas died in 1981- do you have colour photographs for him? Just looking at some of the photos on my wall- Obviously the black and white photos don't show eye colour at all- my Gran, I believe, had blue eyes but I can't tell from the images. I also have several colour photos from the late 1970s but, even on the larger images it's a struggle to see accurate eye colour and the one person that I know had blue eyes looks to have dark/ black eyes even in a colour image.

I am not really an observant person, and unless a person had very striking eyes, I'm not sure I'd really know what colour they were if I was asked at a later time.

Did your Grandfather have brown eyes?

AustinQ

AustinQ Report 7 Feb 2017 11:16

Possible marriage for son George:

First name(s) GEORGE
Last name EDINGTON
Marriage quarter 3
Marriage year 1929
Spouse: Winifred Richardson
Spouse's last name Richardson
District Tynemouth
County Northumberland
Volume 10B Page 449
--------------------------------------------------

wife in 1939:

Edington Household (3 People) 160 Howdon Road , Tynemouth C.B., Northumberland, England

Winifred Edington 15 Jul 1911 Female Unpaid Domestic Duties Married
Lilian Todd (Edington) 01 Nov 1929 Female At School Single
Winifred Mitchinson (Edington) 22 Apr 1933 Female At School Single
Closed Record
------------------------------------------

George's death:
Name: George Edington
Birth Date: 11 Apr 1908
Date of Registration: Sep 1987
Age at Death: 79
Registration district: North Tyneside
Inferred County: Tyne and Wear
Volume: 2 Page: 967
-------------------------------------------------

Looks like Alexander died after the 1911 census:

Birth:
First name(s) ALEXANDER E
Last name WATSON
Birth year 1910
Birth quarter 4
District Tynemouth
County Northumberland
Country England
Volume 10B Page 207

Death:
First name(s) ALEXANDER E
Last name WATSON
Gender Male
Birth year 1911
Age 1
Death quarter 3
Death year 1912
District Tynemouth
County Northumberland
Volume 10B Page 217

AustinQ

AustinQ Report 7 Feb 2017 08:52

1939 register:

Edington Household (6 People) 220 Dudge Road , Tynemouth C.B., Northumberland, England

George Edington 29 Nov 1882 Male Transport Worker Docker Married
Alice Edington 15 Nov 1886 Female Unpaid Domestic Duties Married
Doris Allison (Edington) 14 Feb 1923 Female Shop Assistant General Dealer Single
Irene Carter (Edington) 07 Jun 1925 Female Errand Girl Fruiterers Single
Closed Record
Ronald Edington 29 Dec 1930 Male At School Single
John Dyson 13 Dec 1900 Male General Labourer Widowed
------------------------------------------

Olive is likely the closed record
-----------------------------------------------

George (c1882) is described as Blue eyes, Brown Hair, 5ft 4 3/4 inches on his Service record (1902)

AustinQ

AustinQ Report 7 Feb 2017 08:34

There is this Olive- ?

First name(s) OLIVE
Last name EDINGTON
Birth year 1927
Birth quarter 3
Registration month -
Mother's last name Watson
District Tynemouth
County Northumberland
Country England
Volume 10B Page 427

Chris Ho :)

Chris Ho :) Report 7 Feb 2017 07:35

Have you got a Number from that Discharge Book, or found anything more online regarding Navy?...

Chris :)

http://www.genesreunited.co.uk/boards/board/genealogy_chat/thread/1361946

(a past reference above)


http://www.rootschat.com/forum/index.php?topic=108052.0

(Alexander?)


(a Robert below)

http://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/D8544462

Name Edington, Robert
Place of Birth: North Shields
Number: S 8255
Date of Birth: 18 February 1888


1939 Register (Find My Past)

71 Woodbine Street , South Shields C.B., Durham,

Robert Edington 18 Feb 1888 Male Disabled Sea Going Fireman Last Ship Homecliffe Married
Annie F Edington 28 Jan 1892 Female Unpaid Domestic Duties Married
Florence E Wilson (Edington) 17 Jun 1918 Female Waitress
(written on image, for Robert, Discharge Book No. 618174


Marriages Sep 1917 (>99%)
----------------------------------------------------------------
Edington Robert Smith Gateshead 10a 1399
Smith Annie F Edington Gateshead 10a 1399


Births Jun 1918 (>99%)
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Edington Florence E Smith Gateshead 10a 1845


Marriages Jun 1941 (>99%)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
EDINGTON Florence E Wilson S. Shields 10a 2108
Wilson James H Edington S.Shields 10a 2108

SylviaInCanada

SylviaInCanada Report 7 Feb 2017 01:30

Two possibles for the death ...............

Deaths Dec 1905 (>99%)
EDINGTON Margaret G 0 Tynemouth 10b 117

Deaths Jun 1910 (>99%)
Edington Robert 1 Tynemouth 10b 103



???
WATSON, MARGARET ANN mmn WATSON
GRO Reference: 1905 M Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 304 Occasional Copy: A

Except that is the same year that Thomas Henry was born :-S


and the Robert who died in 1910 has mmn Armstrong.

SylviaInCanada

SylviaInCanada Report 7 Feb 2017 00:53

Incidentally, according to the 1911 Census, Alice had had 4 children, and 1 had died.

They were all living in 1 room

SylviaInCanada

SylviaInCanada Report 7 Feb 2017 00:31

EDINGTON, ROBERT GRUNDY
GRO Reference: 1858 D Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 137

EDINGTON, ANN GRUNDY
GRO Reference: 1861 M Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 158



???
Marriages Sep 1856 (>99%)
Edington George Tynemouth 10b 239
Grundy Jane Tynemouth 10b 239


surname for Alexander misspelled .......

EDDINGTON, ALEXANDER GRUNDY Order
GRO Reference: 1857 M Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 143


It looks as though Alexander's older brother was born before his parents' marriage as no mother's maiden name is shown .....

GRUNDY, JOHN -
GRO Reference: 1854 D Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 123 Order

SylviaInCanada

SylviaInCanada Report 7 Feb 2017 00:21

Alexander in 1871 ............... notice how the family names keep recurring?!!!

1871 Census

Name: Alexander Edington
Age: 14
Estimated birth year: abt 1857
Relation: Son
Father's name: George Edington
Mother's name: Jane Edington
Gender: Male
Where born: Long Benton, Northumberland, England
Civil Parish: Chirton
Ecclesiastical parish: Percy
County/Island: Northumberland
Country: England
Registration district: Tynemouth
Sub-registration district: North Shields
ED, institution, or vessel: 12
Household schedule number: 94/2
Piece: 5115
Folio: 72
Page Number: 18

George Edington 47 b.ca 1824, Scotland, Brick Maker
Jane Edington 39 b.ca 1832, Long Benton, Northumberland
John Edington 16 b.ca 1855, Long Benton, Brick Maker
Alexander Edington 14
Robert Edington 12 b.ca 1859, Long Benton
Ann Edington 10 b.ca 1861, Long Benton
William Edington 7 b.ca 1864, Long Benton
George Edington 3 b.ca 1868, Long Benton
Robert Edington 49 b.ca 1822, Scotland

Address:- Hay Hole


England, Select Births and Christenings, 1538-1975

Name: Alexander Edington
Gender: Male
Baptism Date: 15 Aug 1858
Baptism Place: Longbenton, Northumberland, England
Father: George Edington
Mother: Jane
FHL Film Number: 1469111

SylviaInCanada

SylviaInCanada Report 7 Feb 2017 00:14

Alexander in 1911

1911 Census

Name: Alexander Edington
Age in 1911: 54
Estimated birth year: abt 1857
Relation to Head: Boarder
Gender: Male
Birth Place: North Shields, Northumberland, England
Civil Parish: Tynemouth
Search Photos: Search for 'Tynemouth' in the UK City, Town and Village Photos collection
County/Island: Northumberland
Country: England
Street address: 63 Mill Hill Low Lights N Shields
Marital Status: Widowed
Occupation: Service Fireman <<<<< image reads Screw Fireman
Registration district: Tynemouth
Registration District Number: 559
Sub-registration district: Tynemouth
ED, institution, or vessel: 10
Piece: 30742

Mary Stephenson 60
Edward Elsdon Muir 30
Mayory Ann Muir 25
Edward Elsdon Muir 4
Olav Frede Muir 3
Elizabeth Graham Lancaster 15
William Grysdale 40
Alexander Edington 54 Widowed

SylviaInCanada

SylviaInCanada Report 7 Feb 2017 00:09

Does your mother remember if Olive was older or younger than Thomas Henry???


Incidentally, one of the reasons that I am looking back at Thomas' family is to see if there is anything in his background to indicate his colouring ..........

........ that dark colouring could be either from a black ancestor OR from a Spanish ancestor. You may know that there were a lot of shipwrecked Spanish sailors at many places around the UK after the Spanish Armada. Those that survived intermarried with girls of the area.

SylviaInCanada

SylviaInCanada Report 7 Feb 2017 00:05

This looks like George's birth registration on the new GRO Index, indicating his mother's maiden name was Bigley ......

EDINGTON, GEORGE BIGLEY
GRO Reference: 1883 M Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 175


and his siblings???

EDINGTON, ANN BIGLEY
GRO Reference: 1881 J Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 179

EDINGTON, ALEXANDER BIGLEY
GRO Reference: 1884 S Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 196

EDINGTON, WILLIAM BIGLEY
GRO Reference: 1886 S Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 194

EDINGTON, JANE BIGLEY
GRO Reference: 1888 M Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 198

EDINGTON, ROBERT BIGLEY
GRO Reference: 1888 M Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 197

EDINGTON, HANNAH BIGLEY
GRO Reference: 1891 J Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 212

EDINGTON, ALICE BIGLEY
GRO Reference: 1892 D Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 214

EDINGTON, ALFRED WILLIAM RILEY BIGLEY
GRO Reference: 1893 D Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 207





Kala

Kala Report 6 Feb 2017 23:59

Yes there was an Olive Edington which I can find no record of at all, which I mentioned in my first post, this is one of the many factor that has put a big question mark above Thomas Henry. Yes I do realise this, that's why it he led to confusion because there is a difference in the two birth certificates. I really only mentioned the birth certificates and the siblings because that, along with the inaccurate discription all came across as very suspicious. We had wondered if the Thomas we knew with dark skin and features had taken over the fair skinned, blue eyed Thomas' identity for some reason or another. My mother remembers him as being a lot taller than 5'4. I'm really just looking for insight or theories as to why this description could be wrong or any theories to go with it. Obviously we'll never know for sure.

SylviaInCanada

SylviaInCanada Report 6 Feb 2017 23:56

This looks like George Edington with his family in 1891

1891 Census

Name: George Edington
Age: 8
Estimated birth year: abt 1883
Relation: Son
Father's name: Alexs Edington
Mother's name: Hannah Edington
Gender: Male
Where born: No Shields, Northumberland, England
Civil Parish: North Shields
Ecclesiastical parish: Western Town
Town: No Shields
County/Island: Northumberland
Country: England

Registration district: Tynemouth
ED, institution, or vessel: 4

Piece: 4223
Folio: 72
Page Number: 16

Alexs Edington 34 b.ca 1857, Binton Square, Northumberland, Labourer
Hannah Edington 29 b.ca 1862, Chatham, Kent
Ann Edington 9 b.ca 1882, Howden, Northumberland
George Edington 8
Alexd Edington 6 b.ca 1885, North Shields
Robert Edington 3 b.ca 1888, North Shields

Address:- 1 Waggon Yard

Father's place of birth could be Benton Square according to the image.

SylviaInCanada

SylviaInCanada Report 6 Feb 2017 23:41

Yes, the description in the seamen's discharge book should have been accurate.

SylviaInCanada

SylviaInCanada Report 6 Feb 2017 23:37

Kelsey

you do realise that the baby is not given a surname on his birth certificate don't you?

It is assumed that the baby's surname is the same as the mother's name as given in column 5. If she is unmarried, then only one surname will be shown there. If she is married, then her maiden name will also be shown.

All the names shown in column 2 are the forenames of the baby ......... so if your certificate is showing Thomas Henry Edington in column 2, then those are the baby's 3 forenames.

If the mother's name is shown as Alice Watson in column 5, then she is still unmarried, and the baby's surname is Watson

The father's name is shown in column 4

SylviaInCanada

SylviaInCanada Report 6 Feb 2017 23:32

?? More children

EDINGTON, ALICE WATSON
GRO Reference: 1915 S Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 500


The only Olive Edington I can find is this one .......

Births Sep 1921 (>99%)
Edington Olive Summers Tynemouth 10b 413

She is probably the child of this marriage .......

Marriages Sep 1907 (>99%)
EDINGTON James Newcastle T. 10b 297
SUMMERS Kate Annie Newcastle T. 10b 29

Kala

Kala Report 6 Feb 2017 23:22

Yes he and his brother were both illegitimate, both were given Edington as a forename and Watson as a surname but Thomas dropped it over the years. No it is definitely the right certificate, correct d.o.b, correct mothers name and address - it's definitely him which is why I'm so confused.

The description of him in the seaman's discharge book is bothering me a lot too - it couldn't be any less accurate if they tried. Am I right that they should have been very accurate?

SylviaInCanada

SylviaInCanada Report 6 Feb 2017 23:21

and this looks like him in the 1911 Census

1911 Census

Name: Thomas Edington Watson
Age in 1911: 6
Estimated birth year: abt 1905
Relation to Head: Son
Gender: Male
Birth Place: North Shields, Northumberland, England
Civil Parish: Tynemouth
Search Photos: Search for 'Tynemouth' in the UK City, Town and Village Photos collection
County/Island: Northumberland
Country: England
Street address: 5 Cross Street Milburn Place North Shields
Registration district: Tynemouth
Registration District Number: 559
Sub-registration district: Tynemouth
ED, institution, or vessel: 32
Piece: 30764

George Edington 28 b.ca 1883, North Shields, Northumberland, Fireman at Sea
Alice Edington 24 b.ca 1887, South Shields, Durham, Wife
Thomas Watson 14 b.ca 1897, Aberdeen, Scotland, Boarder
Thomas Edington Watson 6
George Edington Watson 3
Alexander Edington 7/12



WATSON, GEORGE EDINGTON -
GRO Reference: 1908 J Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 270

WATSON, ALEXANDER EDINGTON -
GRO Reference: 1910 D Quarter in TYNEMOUTH Volume 10B Page 207


George Edington married Alice Watson in the December quarter of 1910

Marriages Dec 1910 (>99%)
Edington George Tynemouth 10b 403
Watson Alice Tynemouth 10b 403