Find Ancestors

I have 2 baptism records for a Benjamin Davies, could they be one of the same? or which could be the correct one.
1) Wales, select births and Baptisms 1541-1907
Mother Mary, Father John Davies
Birth 19/03/1819
Baptism 28/2/1821
There is an unusual time lag between the above dates

2) England & Wales Non-conformist Non-Parochial Registers 1567-1970
Mother Mary Davies, Father John Davies
Birth not indicated
Baptism 16/5/1819

The Benjamin I know to be correct got married to Jane Thomas in Wales 1850
Vol 27, Page 49, line 17.
The above wife died and he remarried Elizabeth Jones in Wales 23/12/1858

Could it be Benjamin was Baptized twice for some reason.

Full info

Name: Benjamin Davies
Birth Place: Brongwin, Cardiganshire, Wales
Event Type: Baptism
Father: John Davies
Mother: Mary Davies
Baptism Date: 16 May 1819
Baptism Place: Glynarthen, Cardiganshire, Wales
Denomination: Independent
Piece Title: Piece 3053: Glynarthen, Troedyraur, Hawen (Independent), 1814-1837


Name: Benjamin Davies
Gender: Male
Birth Date: 19 Mar 1819
Baptism Date: 28 Feb 1821
Baptism Place: Llanwenog,Cardigan,Wales
Father: John Davies
Mother: Mary

Where exactly in Wales were these two baptisms? There are lots more baptisms for that name.? Do you know for certain that his parents are John and Mary?

Kath. x

Presumably, you got Benjamin's father's name from his marriage cert...................

The baptism locations are 15 miles apart - quite a long way in the early 19th century

Have you found Benjamin on censuses with birthplace info?

For our reference:

Benjamin Davies
in the England & Wales, Civil Registration Marriage Index, 1837-1915
Name: Benjamin Davies
Registration Year: 1850
Registration Quarter: Jul-Aug-Sep
Registration district: Cardigan
Inferred County: Cardiganshire
Volume: 27
Page: 49
Records on Page:
Name
Benjamin Davies
Jane Thomas


???

Benjamin Davies
in the England & Wales, Civil Registration Marriage Index, 1837-1915
Name: Benjamin Davies
Registration Year: 1858
Registration Quarter: Oct-Nov-Dec
Registration district: Cardigan
Inferred County: Cardiganshire
Volume: 11b
Page: 13
Records on Page:
Name
Benjamin Davies
Elizabeth Jones

Having trouble finding them on censuses - the names are so common, and in 1861 there's no Benjamin/Elizabeth couple in Cardiganshire (assuming that's where they lived) which gives Benjamin's YOB as 1819.

This looks like the most likely ???

Benjamin Davies
in the 1861 Wales Census
Name: Benjamin Davies
Age: 45
Estimated birth year: abt 1816
Relation: Head
Spouse's name: Elizabeth Davies
Gender: Male
Where born: Llanerdcify, Pembrokeshire, Wales
Civil Parish or Township: Cardigan St Mary
County/Island: Cardiganshire
Country: Wales
Street address: View image
Condition as to marriage: View image
Education: View image
Employment status: View image
Occupation: View image
Registration district: Cardigan
Sub-registration district: Cardigan
ED, institution, or vessel: 8
Household schedule number: 60
Neighbors:
Piece: 4175
Folio: 86
Page Number: 12
Household Members:
Name Age
Benjamin Davies 45
Elizabeth Davies 38
Mary Davies 4
John Davies 3/12


EDIT:

But having investigated further, I think this Elizabeth is Elizabeth Evans, who married a Benjamin Davies in 1856.
There are matching children's births.

Marriages Jun 1856 (>99%)
DAVIES Benjamin Cardigan 11b 1
EVANS Elizabeth Cardigan 11b 1

Either of these could be Mary's birth:

DAVIES, MARY EVANS
GRO Reference: 1856 D Quarter in CARDIGAN Volume 11B Page 9

DAVIES, MARY EVANS
GRO Reference: 1857 M Quarter in CARDIGAN Volume 11B Page 8

Possibly John's birth:

DAVIES, JOHN mms EVANS
GRO Reference: 1861 M Quarter in CARDIGAN Volume 11B Page 5

Only record I can find on censuses is 1871, with birthplace Cardiganshire - not much help

Name: Benjamin Dacres
[Benjamin Davies]
Age: 51
Estimated birth year: abt 1820
Relation: Head
Spouse's name: Elizabeth Dacres
Gender: Male
Where born: Cardiganshire, Wales
Civil Parish: Llandygwydd
County/Island: Cardiganshire
Country: Wales
Registration district: Cardigan
Sub-registration district: Llandygwydd
ED, institution, or vessel: 7
Household schedule number: 1
Piece: 5542
Folio: 106
Page Number: 1
Household Members:
Name Age
Benjamin Dacres 51
Elizabeth Dacres 48
Mary Dacres 9
Esther Dacres 8
Owen Dacres 6

DAVIES, OWEN JONES
GRO Reference: 1865 M Quarter in CARDIGAN Volume 11B Page 12

One of these..............

DAVIES, ESTHER JONES
GRO Reference: 1862 J Quarter in CARDIGAN Volume 11B Page 8
DAVIES, ESTHER JONES
GRO Reference: 1863 M Quarter in CARDIGAN Volume 11B Page 14

Not that these are actually of any help,either, in the quest for factual info about Benjamin

It might help to know when and where Jane died.....................

BINGO!

1841

Name: Benjamin Davies
Age: 20
Estimated birth year: abt 1821
Gender: Male
Where born: Cardiganshire, Wales
Civil Parish: Brongwyn
Hundred: Troedyraur
County/Island: Cardiganshire
Country: Wales
Registration district: Newcastle Emlyn
Sub-registration district: Penbryn
Neighbors: View others on page
Piece: 1377
Book: 6
Folio: 5
Page Number: 4
Household Members:
Name Age
John Davies 60
Mary Davies 60
Benjamin Davies 20
Sarah Davies 15

Births of the children in 1871 posted by Erika ??

DAVIES, OWEN mms JONES
GRO Reference: 1865 M Quarter in CARDIGAN Volume 11B Page 12

DAVIES, ESTHER mms JONES
GRO Reference: 1863 M Quarter in CARDIGAN Volume 11B Page 14

Again, there are two or three possible births for Mary.


Possible death of Benjamin ??

Benjamin Davies

in the England & Wales, Civil Registration Death Index, 1837-1915
Name: Benjamin Davies
Estimated birth year: abt 1819
Registration Year: 1871
Registration Quarter: Apr-May-Jun
Age at Death: 52
Registration district: Cardigan
Inferred County: Cardiganshire
Volume: 11b
Page: 10

June, can you confirm, please - and copy/paste if possible -

where did you find the info re his parents' names?
Have you found him on any censuses?

1861??

Name: Benjamin Davies
Age: 40
Estimated birth year: abt 1821
Relation: Head
Spouse's name: Elizabeth Davies
Gender: Male
Where born: Brongwyn, Cardiganshire, Wales
Civil Parish or Township: Llandygwydd
County/Island: Cardiganshire
Country: Wales
Street address: View image
Condition as to marriage: View image
Education: View image
Employment status: View image
Occupation: View image
Registration district: Cardigan
Sub-registration district: Llandygwydd
ED, institution, or vessel: 6
Household schedule number: 85
Neighbors: View others on page
Piece: 4178
Folio: 56
Page Number: 17
Household Members:
Name Age
Benjamin Davies 40
Elizabeth Davies 38
John Davies 9
David Davies 8
Joshua Davies 5


Casts doubts on the 1871 I posted..................

I had discounted that 1861 census because of Joshua's possible birth:

DAVIES, JOSHUA mms EVANS
GRO Reference: 1856 M Quarter in CARDIGAN Volume 11B Page 13

David and John aren't so clear cut.
There are both Davies/Evans and Davies/Jones births which would be possible.

It could also be that Elizabeth wasn't a spinster when she married in 1858

I was going by the birthplace, which matches one of the baptisms, but until the OP comes back with more info, it's all guesswork ;-)

Hi Erika, Definately agree with the 1841 census regarding John father, Mary Mother,Benjamin son & Sarah Daughter. I also agree with 1871 census where Davies had been miss read as Dacres.
With regard to Benjamin I had previously come up with the following conclusion:
Benjamin Davies married Jane Thomas in 1850, (she had previously been married to a Benjamin Evans.). They had 3 children Joshua 1856, David 1853 & John 1852.
This is reflected by the 1861 census.
Sadly by the 1871 census Jane had died and Benjamin remarried Elizabeth Jones and had 3 more children Mary 1862, Ester 1863 & Owen 1865, The original children being in their late teens had all left home. I found them all working as servants.

Have you found Joshua's birth to support your theory about Jane and the children in 1861, please?

I don't see a Joshua Davies, mms Thomas, born in Cardiganshire.

There are a few possibilities for David if your theory's correct:

DAVIES, DAVID mms THOMAS
GRO Reference: 1853 M Quarter in CARDIGAN Volume 11B Page 11

DAVIES, DAVID mms THOMAS
GRO Reference: 1853 J Quarter in NEWCASTLE IN EMLYN Volume 11B Page 25

DAVIES, DAVID mms THOMAS
GRO Reference: 1854 M Quarter in CARDIGAN Volume 11B Page 12

Also for John:

DAVIES, JOHN mms THOMAS
GRO Reference: 1852 M Quarter in CARDIGAN Volume 11B Page 13

DAVIES, JOHN mms THOMAS
GRO Reference: 1852 D Quarter in NEWCASTLE IN EMLYN Volume 11B Page 28

DAVIES, JOHN mms THOMAS
GRO Reference: 1852 D Quarter in NEWCASTLE IN EMLYN Volume 11B Page 28


DAVIES, JOHN mms THOMAS
GRO Reference: 1853 M Quarter in NEW CASTLE IN EMLYN Volume 11B Page 22

There are also Davids and Johns born in other places in Cardiganshire in the approximate years, but I've posted those from Cardigan and Newcastle in Emlyn reg districts as being the most likely.

Have you bought any birth certs to check for the parents' names?

The MMN would be Evans, not Thomas, assuming the births were even registered

June said that she thought Benjamin and Jane (nee Thomas) had had the children Joshua, David, and John, which is what I'm querying.


ADDED:

June -
you said that Jane Thomas had previously been married to an Evans.
Did you perhaps mean that Jane Evans had been married to a Thomas ??

I’m losing the plot here. ;-) ;-)

So am I,
On the 1850 marriage to Jane Thomas, it stated Benjamin's father was John Davies and Jane Thomas's father was David Evans. Jane was a widow so her 1st husband was must have been a Thomas. However I will have to have a complete rethink, the info I have from the 1861 and 1871 census's shows a big floor in my tree as the ages between Benjamin & Elizabeth differ by 14 years. In the 1861 census they are 40 &26 whilst in the 1871 census they are 51 & 48. It is the 1861 census where they are listed with 3 children John, David & Joshua.
As Arnie said (I WILL BE BACK.)

You must have worked back to Benjamin somehow.

Which children do you definitely know are his?

My initial concern on my tree was this floor regarding the age differences I had of Benjamin Davies & his wife Elizabeth Jones who he married in 1858. On the original hand written scripts for the 1861 census it states Benjamin is 40 and it looks like Elizabeth is 26, however on both 1861 census's computerised by Genes Reunited and Find my Past they give the ages as 40 & 38 Ref. RGO9, 56,17, 4178, which I prefer to think are correct. All 3 of these references also state the 3 children John 9 (1852), David 8 (1853) and Joshua 5 (1856), he was actually born in 1855/Christened in 1856, all 3 were from his first marriage.
Regarding Benjamin and his first marriage to Jane Thomas nee Evans on the 12 Sep. 1850, I know Jane's father was called David Evans, but I don't seem able to track down her D.O.B and her mothers name. She also must have died between 1855 when Joshua was born and before 1858 when Benjamin remarried.