Find Ancestors

Are you saying that her age is 28 on her marriage certificate ?

She may have got it wrong / lied.

Age on death certificate is only as good as the informant knows ... or thinks they know.

If she was born Mancester then she was registered in 1904
If she was born 1900 then she wasn't born in Manchester.

Check her birth cert for correct parents to be sure.

Looks like she had her 80th birthday a little early !!!.

Christopher says sisters Frances and May didn't marry.

This death would match the Frances in the 1911 census posted:

Name: Frances Pugh
Birth Date: 22 Jul 1906
Death Registration Month/Year: 1978
Registration district: Manchester
Inferred County: Greater Manchester
Volume: 38
Page: 1366

there is this one born Staffordshire

Gertrude Rugh
[Gertrude Pugh]
Age: 10 Months
Estimated Birth Year: abt 1900
Relation: Daughter
Father's Name: John W Rugh
Mother's Name: Eliza Rugh
Gender: Female
Where born: Staffordshire, England
Civil parish: Wolverhampton
Ecclesiastical parish: All Saints
County/Island: Staffordshire
Household Members: Name Age
John W Rugh 35
Eliza Rugh 34
John Rugh 4
Ada Rugh 2
Gertrude Rugh 10 Months

do you know where Gertrude got married please. There are some Manchester certificates on line

You get her father's name from her marriage certificate, and for that you have to buy it.

http://www.gro.gov.uk/gro/content/

Then you look for them together in the 1911 census, look for her parents' marriage, look for her birth, etc. The marriage certificate might also have a brother or sister as a witness. Do you know whether she had siblings and who they were?

As Flick has said, it's not unusual for birthdates on death records for very old people to be wrong. My grandfather thought he knew he was Edward born 1900 in West Ham. When he retired and got his birth certificate, it turned out he was Edmund born 1901 in West Ham.

But the only way to trace your Gertrude is to get her father's name from her marriage certificate.

I think people are still waiting to know what it is that says James wasn't born in Ireland or however that went.

With a bit of luck Gertrude's marriage certificate will confirm that that is the correct 1911 census posted.

Christopher you say that Gertrude had a sister Frances and one called May. This looks like the marriage for the couple on the 1911 census.

Marriages Dec 1902
Convey Mary Ann Manchester 8d 407
Pugh John Thomas Manchester 8d 407

And a birth for Gertrude's sister May?

Births Jun 1913
Pugh Mary E Convey Manchester 8d 399

The best advice is to buy the marriage certificate. Flick has given you the details. Order it from www.gro.gov.uk/gro/content/certificates/

Once you have this, if your grandfather came from Ireland you can then search for him in the Ireland 1911 census which is free at::
www.census.nationalarchives.ie/

Thanks everyone for your help i am going to buy her marriage cert so i have the real facts as this has been doing my head in for days now

No documents prove for her going to try and buy one online so i can get her mum&dads names and she had 2 sisters MAY(think thats how you spell it) FRANCES PUGH they never married they lived in manchester dont know where went up a few time when i was younger p.s. sorry for being a slow typer :)

Buy her marriage cert..........the only way to get FACTS

For all you know, Gertrude could have been born in Ireland

Christopher, the birth year might be wrong on the death entry - this is quite a common problem. Alternatively, she might have been born somewhere else.
You have no option but to get Gertrude's marriage cert.
Jan

What does that prove if you do not have the birth cert? so she told everyone she was born 1900 have you seen it on any documents?

jax

And also i dont have birth cert for my nan.. No sorry i dont have her dads name ??? only know her hubby JAMES NAUGHTON from mayo in ireland :)

sorry for being a bit slow at getting back but not fast at this typing my grans name
GERTRUDE PUGH
born SEPT 1900
MANCHESTER
died JAN 1984
she was 83 when died she had a 80th party a few years earlier n we lived next door my nan all our life in middleton manchester
married JAMES NAUGHTON in 1928 i dont have any information on my grandad as he was not around when i was born.. Believed he died around 1980-90's come from county mayo thanks again :)

Christopher, we all want to help but need to know what you know. Gertrude's father's name is important in finding her 1911.
Jan

Do you have ANY documentary evidence relating to Gertrude?

OK, she married and died in Manchester..........that doesn't mean she was born there

How do you know your nans dob? I thought I knew my grandads but I did'nt!!!



jax

Sorry, but you don't KNOW her birth date if you don't have her birth CERT

'Won't show' what?

You've lost me...........

Marriages Sep 1928 (>99%)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Pugh Gertrude Naughton Manchester N. 8d 1605

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Births Dec 1904 (>99%)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Pugh Gertrude Manchester 8d 195


WHO was her father?