Find Ancestors

I have 6 children that i can prove are Harry's children, have tried Family Search no joy, thanks all for your work

Have you established beyond doubt who the 8 'living' offspring were?

Ian

Usually with overseas research you need to know exactly where they come from as records are often kept locally. Kiev now Kyiv is mentioned, which I am sure you know is the capital of the Ukraine. You have to consider whether this is really the right time to follow this line.
Unless you can find them on Family Search. Babies who died shortly after birth may not have even been registered but are remembered,

It's the 1910 census which says 12 children born, 8 living.

The 12 children came from a census record (1920 or 30 cannot remember) states 12 children born 8 living, they may have been born in Russia (if so how can i find them)?

If Harry did indeed father 12 children Could some of the 12 have been born in Russia but not survived long enough to emigrate.

The naturalisation record posted by ErikaH is maybe for the man with wife Mollie, whom Ian has rejected?

Harry Stein
in the New York, U.S., State and Federal Naturalization Records, 1794-1943
Name: Harry Stein
Petition Age: 56
Record Type: Naturalization Petition
Birth Date: 10 Apr 1868
Birth Place: Zitomev, Russia
Departure Place: Hamburg, Germany
Arrival Date: 1 Apr 1906
Arrival Place: New York
Petition Date: 21 Jan 1925
Petition Place: New York, USA
Ship: Citta Di Napoli
Spouse:
Mollie

Same date of birth - but different arrival year stated.


Incidentally, on the record posted by ErikaH, against Date of Naturalization on the image it says "Denied".
Witnesses: Esrock Stein, 808 Dempster Street, Evanston
and Jacob Fred Stein, 445 E 71st Street

Is this the same man reapplying in 1925?

??

Name: Harry Stein
Naturalization Age: 47
Record Type: Naturalization
Birth Date: 10 Jun 1868
Birth Place: Russia
Year of Arrival: 1907
Naturalization Date: 28 Apr 1916

How do you know he fathered 12 children?

United States Naturalization Petitions
New York, United States


First name(s) Gilbert
Description Petitions for naturalization from the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, 1824-1945 NARA RG21 publication M1972
Last name Stein
Publication title Rec Of Naturalization U S District Court So District Of Ny
Birth year 1901
Publication year 1999
Birth date 22 Oct 1901
Volume reference 1
Birth country Russia
Declaration 58574
Birth place as transcribed Kiev, Russia
Country United States
Event year 1926
Record set United States Naturalization Petitions
Event type Petition for naturalization
Category Travel & migration
Event state New York
Subcategory Naturalizations

This is the family according to trees on ancestry. Harry born Ukraine.

US Census 1910
Bronx Assembly District 34, New York, United States

Household members (8 people)
First name(s) Last name Relationship Marital status Gender Age Birth year
Harry Stein Self Married Male 38 1872
Alta Stein Wife Married Female 40 1870
Jacob Stein Son Single Male 20 1890
Morris Stein Son Single Male 16 1894
Ida Stein Daughter Single Female 11 1899
Gilbert Stein Son Single Male 9 1901
Richard Stein Son Single Male 4 1906
Max Stein Son Single Male 2 1908


Harry Stein

in the New York, U.S., State Census, 1915

Name: Harry Stein
Birth Year: abt 1868
Birth Place: Russia
Age: 47
Gender: Male
Residence Place: New York, Bronx
Relationship: Head
Color or Race: White
Number of years in US: 13
Assembly District: 34
House Number: 1742
Line Number: 26
Page number: 07
Household Members Age Relationship
Harry Stein 47 Head
Esther Stein
48 Wife
Ida Stein
17 Daughter
Gilbert Stein
14 Son
Richard Stein
8 Son



US Census 1920
Bronx, New York, United States

Household members (7 people)
First name(s) Last name Relationship Marital status Gender Age Birth year Birth place
Harry Stein Self Married Male 52 1868 Russia
Olga Stein Wife Married Female 53 1867 Russia
Ethel Novak Daughter Widowed Female 32 1888 Russia
Gilbert Stein Son Single Male 18 1902 Russia
Richard Stein Son Single Male 13 1907 New York
Rose Novak Granddaughter Single Female 11 1909 New York
Jacob Novak Grandson Single Male 9 1911 New York


US Census 1930
Bronx, New York, United States

Household members (4 people)
First name(s) Last name Relationship Marital status Sex Age Birth year Birth place
Harry Stein Head Married Male 60 1870 Russia
Olga Stein Wife Married Female 60 1870 Russia
Ethel Nowak Daughter Widowed Female 43 1887 Russia
Richard Stein Son Single Male 24 1906 New York


Harry emigrated in 1902, Olga and Ethel in 1905.

Please C&P the census record(s) to which you refer………

no to all the above, his wife is listed with several names, olga, esther, alta on 1910 us census second child Jacob 1890, morris 1894

Who did the man marry?

Is this the right Harry Stein and family in the 1910 US census - says all but Wally b Russia and immigrated 1906

Name: Harry Stein
Age in 1910: 41
Birth Date: 1869
[1869]
Birthplace: Russia
Home in 1910: Brooklyn Ward 26, Kings, New York, USA
Street: Sutter Avenue
House Number: 595
Race: White
Gender: Male
Immigration Year: 1906
Relation to Head of House: Head
Marital Status: Married
Spouse's Name: Molly Stein
Father's Birthplace: Russia
Mother's Birthplace: Russia
Native Tongue: English
Occupation: Retail Grocer
Industry: Store
Employer, Employee or Other: Own Account
Home Owned or Rented: Rent
Farm or House: House
Naturalization Status: Alien
Able to read: Yes
Able to Write: Yes
Years Married: 18
Neighbors: View others on page
Household Members Age Relationship
Harry Stein 41 Head
Molly Stein 34 Wife
Sam Stein 16 Son
Daniel Stein 13 Son
Rose Stein 11 Daughter
Polly Stein 9 Daughter
David Stein 6 Son
Wally Stein 2 Son
Beny Jaffe 43 Brother-in-law

1915 census has children - Sam 21, Daniel 18, Rosa 13, Davith 10 and
K(H)alman 8 (is this Wally from 1910 or another child?)

1920 - Samuel 24, Daniel 22, Ruth 19, Pauline 16, David 16 and Kalman 11

NO - Can't be this Harry

His 1919 Naturalisation documents say this Harry had 6 children and gives place and date of birth. They give date of arrival in USA as 1 April 1906

Samuel b Russia
Daniel
Rose
Pauline
David
Kalmen - b Brooklyn

Perhaps you could post a census that they are on, name his wife and other children

Need help in finding the 12 children of Harry Stein b 1868 Russia, was in USA from 1905 he died in 1946. Found some from US census & a tree on Ancestry but cannot find rest. First child ethel b 1888. Many thanks