Profile | Posted by | Options | Post Date |
|
ArgyllGran
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 10:39 |
Re the name Janet on Alexander's death cert -
Who was the informant? Any info would depend on what the informant knew (or thought they knew) - not necessarily correct.
ADDED: I've had a look - the informant was Alexander's grandson, who may very well not have known accurately what his great-grandmother's name was.
|
|
Chris Ho :)
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 12:19 |
A Brother of Robert...
https://www.freereg.org.uk/
Chris :)
County Ayrshire Place Dunlop Church name Church of Scotland Parish Church Register type Unspecified Birth date 24 Jan 1830 Baptism date 31 Jan 1830 Person forename John Person sex M Father forename Alexr Father surname WATT Mother surname STEVENSON Person abode Longton
County Ayrshire Place Dunlop Church name Church of Scotland Parish Church Register type Unspecified Birth date 04 Jul 1831 Baptism date 24 Jul 1831 Person forename Robert Person sex M Father forename Alexr Mother forename Marion Father surname WATT Mother surname STEVENSON Person abode Langton
County Ayrshire Place Dunlop Church name Church of Scotland Parish Church Register type Unspecified Marriage date 03 Mar 1829 Groom forename Alexr Groom surname WATT Groom occupation Wright Bride forename Marion Bride surname STEVENSON Bride parish Neilston
(another about!)
County Ayrshire Place Dunlop Church name Church of Scotland Parish Church Register type Unspecified Birth date 25 Jun 1828 Person forename Robert Person sex M Father forename Alexr Mother forename Agnes Father surname WATT Mother surname WATT Person abode Mosside
County Ayrshire Place Dunlop Church name Church of Scotland Parish Church Register type Unspecified Marriage date 16 Feb 1826 Groom forename Alexr Groom surname WATT Groom occupation Farmer Bride forename Agnes Bride surname WATT
|
|
ErikaH
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 12:28 |
Not yet proved that the Robert in question was born in Scotland. Census returns for him in 1881 and later say he was born in England
|
|
ArgyllGran
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 13:07 |
There's no Robert Watt aged 78-82 anywhere in Scotland in 1911.
Nor did he die in Scotland. I've used some credits and looked at the two Robert Watt deaths of the right age, 1901-1930 - neither of them is the right man.
One's in East Kilbride, a farmer, single, parents James Watt & Margaret Browning. Informant: brother Gavin.
The other died in Stromness - so not likely in any case!. Widower of Isabella McGregor. A coach hirer. Parents James Watt & Betsy Oag.
|
|
ArgyllGran
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 13:16 |
If he died in England, this is the only death (1901-30) which matches what his age would be - assuming the informant got it right:
Deaths Mar 1906 (>99%) WATT Robert 75 Durham 10a 234
Robert Watt in the England, Select Deaths and Burials, 1538-1991 Name: Robert Watt Gender: Male Burial Date: 13 Jan 1906 Burial Place: Durham, Durham, England FHL Film Number: 2104078 Reference ID: p336
|
|
rootgatherer
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 13:26 |
Having read through the thread, for what it's worth, I agree with ErikaH. There is no evidence to prove that Robert was born in Scotland. Also as no marriage or death certificate has been found, I don't see how anyone knows his parents' names.
Given the age difference between Robert and Mary, perhaps he wasn't free to marry her.
I think it may be necessary to trawl through earlier census to try to identify him before he was with Mary.
If it is known where Mary was buried, it may be worth finding out who is buried in the same grave.
|
|
rootgatherer
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 14:17 |
In 1871, Robert also gives his birthplace as England but a birth year of 1841.
1871 England, Wales & Scotland Census Kirk Close, Dalry, Ayrshire, Scotland
First name(s) Last name Relationship Marital status Sex Age Birth year Occupation Birth place
Robert Watt Head Married Male 30 1841 Labourer England Mary Watt Wife Married Female 24 1847 - Glasgow, Ayrshire, Scotland
|
|
rootgatherer
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 14:49 |
Is this not the death of Robert son of Alexander Watt and Marion Stevenson?
Age at death Mother's Maiden Name Year Ref RD Name Image View WATT ROBERT 25 STEVENSON 1856 599/ 76 Kilwinning
I'm struggling to see where you have got the names of your Robert's parents. Can you tell us please where you found their names? I'm just a little concerned that you are following the wrong Watt family backwards from your Robert.
|
|
ErikaH
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 15:00 |
There’s a baptism on SP which is the source of the ‘info’. It has obviously been latched onto after the census was found showing a birthplace of Dunlop, but without any corroboration.
Your 1871 makes more sense in view of the man’s occupation
|
|
ArgyllGran
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 15:27 |
When you look at Robert on the 1901 census on Ancestry, Ancestry suggests that he's the Robert with father Alexander in 1841.
Either Lindsey or her friend has assumed that that's correct, instead of just a suggestion.
But even then, that's not the Robert whose mother was Marion - he's another Robert , born 1829, with mother Agnes.
|
|
greyghost
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 15:41 |
Just to complete the census set of Robert Watt with parents Alexander and Marion.
BUT as I noted on Page 1 of this thread - Robert shows as born England on the census with wife Mary.
Lindsey you need to tell us how you / your friend got back to the family with any certainty. What do you know for sure with what proof.
1841 England, Wales & Scotland Census
Corsehill, Kilwinning, Ayrshire, Scotland
First name(s) Last name Sex Age Birth year Birth place Alexander Watt Male 40 1801 Ayrshire, Scotland Marion Watt Female 35 1806 Ayrshire, Scotland John Watt Male 11 1830 Ayrshire, Scotland Robert Watt Male 9 1832 Ayrshire, Scotland Janet Watt Female 7 1834 Ayrshire, Scotland Alexander Watt Male 3 1838 Ayrshire, Scotland James Watt Male 0 1841 Ayrshire, Scotland
|
|
rootgatherer
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 17:54 |
My gut feeling is that Alexander and Marion Watt are not the correct family for your Robert Watt and that it's pointless adding their ancestors to your Robert's tree.
In my opinion, you need to checkout the other Watts in Ayrshire to see if any of them also give a birthplace of England. I think that without a marriage or death for your Robert it may prove impossible to determine his parents. It may also be worth looking at the original image (on Scotlandspeople) to double check on Robert's age and place of birth (you never know, it may give a county).
|
|
Chris Ho :)
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 18:16 |
When was this Death of Alexander, and Address? (apologies if I've missed it somewhere!)
Chris :)
|
|
Lindsey
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 18:52 |
Thank you Mary died aged 51 in 1900 the family in Stevenson is them I’m sure as John their son born in 1887 is our link. Their son a John was born at Ardeer so am sure it’s them in 1881 in Stevenson Roberts occupation in 1887 is a labourer plasterer. I have found a newspaper article of Robert Watt a labourer assaulting his wife Mary Halbert in Stevenson. The marriage for Alexander Watt and Marion Stevenson is for Dunlop in the Parish of Nielston. Janet watt appears on Alexander Watts death record in 1884 as him mother
|
|
rootgatherer
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 19:01 |
Lindsey, I think we need to know where you have found proof that Alexander Watt and Marion Stevenson are connected to your Robert Watt. At the moment, as I understand it, no one else has been able to find the connection.
Have you found Robert Watt born ENGLAND with any of his family on census records prior to 1871 please?
|
|
Chris Ho :)
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 19:19 |
1894 Newspaper article says...assaulted his wife, Mary Halbert or Watt...
Chris :)
1891 Robert Watt Head Married Male 60 1831 Foundry Labourer England Mary Watt Wife Married Female 41 1850 - Ayrshire, Scotland Janet Watt Daughter Unmarried Female 17 1874 - Ayrshire, Scotland Mary Watt Daughter - Female 15 1876 - Ayrshire, Scotland Sarah Watt Daughter - Female 14 1877 - Ayrshire, Scotland Thomas Watt Son - Male 8 1883 Scholar Ayrshire, Scotland George Watt Son - Male 6 1885 Scholar Ayrshire, Scotland John Watt Son - Male 4 1887 - Ayrshire, Scotland David Watt Son - Male 0 1891 - Ayrshire, Scotland Townhead Street, Stevenston, Ayrshire, Scotland
|
|
alviegal
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 19:25 |
Ardrossan and Saltcoats Herald 08 June 1894
This is the article about Robert Watt, labourer of Main Street, Stevenston striking his wife.
Daughter Janet's birth.
Janet Last name Watt Gender Female Birth year 1873 Birth place Ardrossan,Ayr,Scotland Father's first name(s) Robert Father's last name Watt Mother's first name(s) Mary Mother's last name Halbert
|
|
ArgyllGran
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 19:57 |
Just for the record -
the sons Thomas, George and David in 1901:
David Watt in the 1901 Scotland Census Name: David Watt Age: 11 Estimated birth year: abt 1890 Relationship: Boarder Gender: Male Where born: Stevenston, Ayr Registration Number: 615 Registration district: Stevenston Civil Parish: Stevenston Town: Stevenston County: Ayrshire Address: Line Kn Rd Occupation: Scholar ED: 5 Household schedule number: 97 Line: 15 Roll: CSSCT1901_237 Household Members: Name Age Henry Sommerville 33 Janet F Sommerville 24 Mary F Sommerville 6 Janet F Sommerville 5 Agnes F Sommerville 3 John F Sommerville 2 Mo Thomas H Watt 18 George Watt 16 David Watt 11
|
|
ArgyllGran
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 20:07 |
Chris, you asked about Alexander's death:
Alexander Watt, joiner journeyman, married to Marion Stevenson. 1884, February 9th, 10hrs 5min a.m., at Pathfoot, Kilwinning. 84 years. Parents: John Watt, mason, deceased. Janet Watt, ms Wylie, deceased. Cause of death: natural decay. Informant: Alexander Watt, grandson, Eglinton Iron Works, Kilwinning.
WATT ALEXANDER 84 1884 599/ 14 Kilwinning
Lindsey - there is no documentary evidence that the Robert in 1871, 1881, 1891, 1891, born England in all of them, is the Robert who is the son of Alexander and Marion. And RG has shown what seems very likely to be the death of A&M's son in 1856.
|
|
Chris Ho :)
|
Report
|
16 Nov 2019 20:57 |
(thankyou AG, just in case there was anything newspapers!. Grandson seems to have been Clerk in Iron Works on 1891, 1901 with Mary)
Chris :)
(as said, without the Marriage, no way of knowing for sure the Father of Robert...Tricky!)
|