Profile | Posted by | Options | Post Date |
|
Moody Blue
|
Report
|
11 Sep 2012 10:31 |
Anne, I do not know just how much to believe and that is why I am trying to prove/disprove whatever.
On Thomas marriage certificate 1855 on previous page it says that both Allan Mark and his wife Isabell are deceased.
On Helens marriage certificate it does NOT say that Adam Mark is deceased but that his wife Mary nee Phillips is.
On Janes marriage certificate 1862 to James Reid her age is 23yrs making year of birth 1839 which connects to the census both in Scotland and in Utah.
I dont want to give any untrue info and that is why I try to check on it.
Some of the info has bits that are correct but a lot more is sort of twisted around the truth but have found that before with many Lds info.
|
|
GlasgowLass
|
Report
|
11 Sep 2012 00:25 |
Hi Moody Blue, I wonder where the birth dates for Jane and Mary Mark came from? These births are not on SP ( anywhere Scotland). I would have expected that the OPRs would be transcribed. All of the trees have Carnwath as their place of birth, yet all the other family births on family search show that the children were baptized in Shotts. It is possible that the bapt entries for Shotts state place of birth was Carnwath, but without looking at it, we cannot be sure?
I wonder if the girls provided their dobs after they arrived in Utah for LDS records.
I have come across these Archibalds in Utah before, but I deleted every one of them from my tree a long time ago I decided that my tree should only contain direct line descendants of common ancestors.
If I recall, they linked somewhere to OH's family who originate in Inveresk, Midlothian.
EDIT: Most ANC trees have the same 1854 death date for Adam Mark b 1819. There is no death on SP taken from any OPR If this was a definitive death date, then it would refer to another Adam Mark as the one b1819 was still living at 1871. A few trees have the 1854 death added to both Adam b 1819 AND his grandfather Adam b 1770
|
|
Moody Blue
|
Report
|
11 Sep 2012 00:20 |
I'm off now but be back tomorrow or later today.....another late night!!
|
|
Moody Blue
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 23:39 |
DO NOT accept this info as entirely correct....more confirmation is required.
Jane Mark / Reid / Archibald ??
1880 United States Federal Census about Jane Archibald Name: Jane Archibald Age: 41 Birth Year: abt 1839 Birthplace: Scotland Home in 1880: Clarkston, Cache, Utah Race: White Gender: Female Relation to Head of House: Wife Marital Status: Married Spouse's Name: James Archibald Father's Birthplace: Scotland Mother's Birthplace: Scotland Neighbors: View others on page Occupation: Keeping House Cannot read/write:
Blind:
Deaf and dumb:
Otherwise disabled:
Idiotic or insane: View image Household Members: Name Age James Archibald 44 Jane Archibald 41 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>William Reel 17 (Reed ? ) May Archibald 12 Alexander Archibald 10 Margaret Archibald 7 Robert J. Archibald 4 Mary Archibald 44 Thomas M. Archibald 22 Isabella Archibald 20 James Archibald 18 Allen Archibald 16 William W. Archibald 12 Mary E. Archibald 10
|
|
GlasgowLass
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 23:27 |
I get it now.....The penny has finally dropped.
Walter and George Scott were brothers. Both were sons of John Scott and Agnes Robb. Which means... they married sisters!
Walter married Isabella Mark. Dau of Adam Mark and Mary Phillip George married Helen Mark daughter of Adam Mark and Mary Philip Here is John and Agnes Scott in 1841
1841 Scotland Census about John Scott Name: John Scott Age: 28 Estimated Birth Year: abt 1813 Gender: Male Where born: Lanarkshire, Scotland Civil parish: Carluke County: Lanarkshire Address: Stewart St Occupation: Iron M Parish Number: 629 Household Members: Name Age John Scott 28 Agness Scott 25 Jane Scott 6 Agness Scott 4 Marion Scott 2
1861 Sisters Agnes and Rachael Scott Both children are entered as Agnes's daughters 1861 Scotland Census about Agnes Scott Name: Agnes Scott Age: 23 Estimated Birth Year: abt 1838 Relationship: Head Gender: Female Where born: Larkhall, Lanark Registration Number: 629 Registration district: Carluke Civil parish: Carluke County: Lanarkshire Address: Stewart Street Occupation: Seamstress ED: 2 Household schedule number: 63 Line: 25 Roll: CSSCT1861_93 Household Members: Name Age Agnes Scott 23 Rachael Scott 16 Janet Brown 4 Agnes Grierson 2
Anne
|
|
Moody Blue
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 22:29 |
Helen Scott nee Mark 1881
1881 Scotland Census about Helen Scott Name: Helen Scott Age: 32 Estimated Birth Year: abt 1849 Relationship: Wife Spouse's name : George Scott Gender: Female Where born: Whitburn, Linlithgow Registration Number: 673/2 Registration district: Fauldhouse Civil parish: Whitburn County: West Lothian Address: 174 East Benhar Occupation: Oversman'S Wife ED: 1 Household schedule number: 136 Line: 10 Roll: cssct1881_274 Household Members: Name Age George Scott 33 Helen Scott 32 Agnes Scott 11 Isabella Scott 9 Helen Scott 7 John Scott 5 Adam Scott 2 John Hurness 15 Philip Clark 4 Christina Clark 1
|
|
GlasgowLass
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 22:07 |
Hi , Just catching up... The 1841 cenus in Tollcross, Shettleston Yes, this is definitely Adam Mark and Mary Philips The married just ahead of the 1841 census. Which is why.... Adam does not appear with his parents on the 1841 return.
The info is somewhere on this thread but I am also having probs finding it all again.
Good find on the marriages for Jane and Helen Mark. I am pretty certain that Jane was the daughter of Allan Mark ( not William) and there will be an error on the 1863 marriage
Next step is to find them.... and see what their kids are called!
Anne
|
|
Moody Blue
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 21:40 |
Lets throw another one in then!!
marriage Helen Mark & George Scott June 3rd 1867 Wishaw
George Scott bachelor, coalminer, age 21, Newarkhill in the parish of Bothwell father JOHN SCOTT coalminer mother:- AGNES SCOTT M.S. ROBB deceased
Helen Mark X witnessed by Hugh Gaffney & Adam Mark Spinster, age 18, Newarkhill in the parish of Bothwell father :- ADAM MARK coalminer mother:- MARY MARK m.s. philps deceased (Phillips????)
Witnesses :- Adam Mark & James Mark
...................................................................
John Scott b1812c is the father of Walter Scott father of JohnScott b1865
probable wrongly transcribed in the mothers name.......
1851 Scotland Census about John Scott
>>>>>>>>>>>>>Name: John Scott Age: 39 Estimated Birth Year: abt 1812 Relationship: Head >>>>>>>Spouse's Name: Agnes Robb Gender: Male Where born: Dalserf, Lanark Parish Number: 629 Civil parish: Carluke County: Lanarkshire Address: 15 Dyke Row Occupation: Ironstone Miner ED: 11 Page: 34 (click to see others on page) Household schedule number: 102 Line: 8 Roll: CSSCT1851_150 Household Members: Name Age John Scott 39 Agnes Robb 37 Jane Robb 16 Agnes Robb 14 Marion Robb 12 >>>>>>>>>>Walter Robb 10 (Walter Scott) Rachel Robb 7 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>George Robb 4 ( George Scott)
|
|
Moody Blue
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 21:25 |
Hi Eringobragh1916
Yes, I would think so. He was born 1819 so age fits, he married Mary Phillips so I would tend to believe it is.
How are you.....you're not alone...I'm confused too!
|
|
Moody Blue
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 21:15 |
This one is a little odd????
marriage 31 December 1862 at Marshall Street Wishaw after banns according to the Established Church of Scotland
James Reid, bachelor, coalminer, age 22, Marshall Street Wishaw father :_ William Reid Journeyman Baker mother :_ Agnes Reid m.s. Greirson deceased.
Jane Mark, Domestic Servant, Spinster age 23 , Marshall Street Wishaw father :- WILLIAM MARK, coalminer, deceased mother :- ISABELLA MARK m.s. BROWN deceased
witnesses :- Hugh Gardiner & HELEN MARK
registered January 20th 1863 at Wishaw.
This does put in question as to whom really were her parents and possibly Helens????
|
|
Eringobragh1916
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 20:58 |
Evening MoodyBlue...
Is this do you think Adam son of Allan and Isabelle and his ? wife Mary Phillips Address: Tollcross Shettleston
1841 Census -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Surname First name(s) Sex Age Occupation Where Born MARK Adam M 20 Coal Miner Lanarkshire MARK Mary F 20 Lanarkshire
Totally bamboozled....!!
|
|
Moody Blue
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 20:39 |
marriage for Thomas Mark july 6th 1855
Thomas Mark age 24 Wishaw, Coal mine, bachelor born & registered at benham Shotts lanarkshire 16 Feb 1831 father Allan Mark decd coal miner mother Isabella Mark m.s. Brown decd.
Janet Denham X witness James Mark , David Craig age 23 , Wishaw, Domestic servant, Spinster. born & registered NewartHill, Holytown Lanarkshire 13 apr 1832 father Alexr Denham decd coal miner mother Janet Denham m.s. Thomson decd
witnesses James Mark & David Craig
note both parents of Thomas are deceased by 1855
|
|
Moody Blue
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 19:40 |
have replied to you Anne via pm.
|
|
GlasgowLass
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 19:11 |
Mary Mark maiden Name Phillips Died in Calderhead, Lanarkshire in 1863
|
|
OneFootInTheGrave
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 17:52 |
Anne & Moody Blue,
Thank you both for these latest updates, I will deal with them tomorrow as I am going to call it a day as I have been punching this keyboard since 04:00am this morning.
Thanks for Bernad's war records, looks like he was as much of a reprobate as his brother Joseph.
Goodnight All
James
|
|
Moody Blue
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 17:22 |
Re this tree on Anc it does say Allen's father was in fact Adam Mark 1770 =1854 and his wife was Elizabeth Cherry 1770 - ?
|
|
GlasgowLass
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 16:55 |
James, Re names Scottish families tended to adhere to the traditional naming pattern. Names were not chosen, but allocated in a specific order If a child died, it was usual for the next child of the same gender to be allocated the name..... (the name relates to ancestry. It is not given memory of the previously deceased child), 1st son.. named for father's father 2nd son named for mother's father 3rd son named for his own father
1st daughter... named for mother's mother 2nd daughter named for father's mother 3rd daughter... named for her own mother
By looking at the children and grandchildren of Allan Mark and Isabella Brown, and the order that they were named, it is starting to produce a pattern that suggests that Allan Mark's father was called ADAM MARK
Anne
|
|
GlasgowLass
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 16:49 |
Hi james, I have been trying to work at all the children born to Allan Mark and Isobel Brown. Allan and Isobel married on 21 Jan 1816 There are only 6 children listed on Family search all born Shotts
ISOBEL Mark b 20 Dec 1816 According to a tree on Ancestry that needs to be confirmed, she married Michael Hendry in Carnwath 1835. Names of children look about right and include Isabella, Allan and Adam This family moved to UTAH!
ADAM Mark b 25 Jun 1819 .... Your direct line married Mary Phillip in Barony 18 Apr 1841 Lived in Whitburn, West Lothian until 1871 but I can find no death for him. Most of his children ( and their spouses) can be positively identified living in West Lothian until 1901
ALEXANDER Mark b 23 Jun 1822. Married Catherine circa 1845 and can be found in Whiburn, West Lothian until 1871.
JAMES Mark b 1 Nov 1826 Married Janet circa 1852. and lived in Shotts until 1861 This family is found in Barclay, Bradford, PA from 1870 onwards
THOMAS FOREST Mark b 16 Feb 1831 Married Janet Denham in Cambusnethan 1855 Lived in Shotts until 1861 and can be found in Barclay, Bradford PA from 1870 onwards
JANET Mark b 30 Apr 1833
I have not added the next generation in any of these families..... info overload at this stage!
Anne
|
|
Moody Blue
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 16:20 |
I've noticed that the names jean and Jane are commonly interchanged so maybe this is the jean Mark on 1841 census, Both are born Bothwell.
1861 Scotland Census about Jane Mark Name: Jane Mark Age: 21 Estimated Birth Year: abt 1840 Relationship: Visitor Gender: Female Where born: Bothwell, Lanarkshire Registration Number: 628 Registration district: Cambusnethan Civil parish: Cambusnethan Town: Wishaw County: Lanarkshire Address: Caledonian Road ED: 7 Household schedule number: 186 Line: 4 Roll: CSSCT1861_93 Household Members: Name Age Daniel Mcneil 41 Margaret R Mcneil 40 Duncan Mcneil 19 John Mcneil 14 Margaret Mcneil 12 Malcolm Mcneil 7 Mary Mcneil 2 >>>>>>>>>>>Jane Mark 21 Helen Mark 71
|
|
Moody Blue
|
Report
|
10 Sep 2012 14:40 |
Re Michael McCue
Perhaps the 1st Michael died. He does not seem to appear on the 1891 census only the 1881?
Possibly his death as same area as 1881 census
1881 MCCUE MICHAEL M 3 OLD MONKLAND (WESTERN DISTRICT) /LANARK 652/01 0100
|